Checked. A Pet's Present gives 2 coins of your level's kind at every level: Iron, Bronze, Silver, Gold, then Platinum at 50. That is how our version's data has it, and the only other reference we have, from a later version of the game, gives 2 to 3, not 1. The "classic" one-coin rule may come from the later Classic release. We have passed your note on to the server owner, who can lower the Gold and Platinum rewards if wanted.